Arby’s Horsey Sauce

Jump to Recipe

If there’s one sauce that stands out at Arby’s, it’s Horsey Sauce. Known for its creamy base and bold horseradish kick, this sauce transforms simple sandwiches into crave-worthy meals. While the fast-food packets disappear fast, making Horsey Sauce at home lets you keep that tangy goodness within easy reach. Whether you slather it on roast beef or use it to elevate burgers, this copycat recipe nails both flavor and texture.

Why Make Horsey Sauce at Home?

Store-bought horsey sauce is convenient, but the homemade version comes with clear benefits:

• Adjust the heat level to your preference.
• Control the ingredients for a fresher taste.
• Make as much as you need so you never run out during a cookout.

If you’ve ever wondered what gives this sauce its “zing,” it all centers on prepared horseradish and mayo, balanced with sweetness. These pantry staples merge to create a smooth spread that compliments nearly any savory dish.

Essential Ingredients

Arby’s Horsey Sauce requires minimal ingredients, but balance is key. Here’s what you’ll need:

Ingredient Notes:

• Mayonnaise: Use your favorite brand or homemade. Full-fat mayo yields the creamiest sauce.
• Horseradish: Cream-style prepared horseradish is closest to Arby’s texture. If using fresh, grate fine and use less.
• Sugar: Granulated works best, but powdered can dissolve more quickly.
• Vinegar and salt: These are optional. A small splash of vinegar brightens the sauce, while a pinch of salt brings balance.

Equipment

• Medium mixing bowl
• Whisk or spoon
• Measuring cups and spoons
• Airtight container for storage

Step-by-Step Recipe

1. Measure and Combine

Add the following to your bowl:

• 1 cup mayonnaise
• 2 tablespoons prepared horseradish
• 1 tablespoon sugar
• 1 teaspoon white vinegar (optional)
• Pinch of salt (optional)

2. Mix Thoroughly

Use your whisk or spoon to blend all the ingredients until the mixture looks smooth. If you see small bits of horseradish, that’s fine—these add character.

3. Taste and Adjust

Sample the sauce. If you want more heat, add another teaspoon of horseradish. For extra tang, increase the vinegar in half-teaspoon increments. Too spicy? Mix in more mayo and a pinch of sugar.

4. Chill

Transfer your sauce to an airtight jar. Refrigerate for at least 30 minutes before using. This resting time allows flavors to mellow and merge, giving the sauce greater depth.

How to Customize Your Horsey Sauce

Homemade sauces are all about personalization. Here are a few ways you can tweak Horsey Sauce to suit your palate:

• Make it lighter: Substitute light mayo or Greek yogurt for a lower-calorie option.
• Boost the kick: Use extra-hot horseradish or add a pinch of white pepper.
• Try a vegan version: Use vegan mayo; flavor remains close to the classic.
• Go sugar-free: Sweeten with honey, agave, or stevia rather than granulated sugar.

Flavor Twists

• A spoonful of Dijon mustard layers in subtle notes.
• Smoked paprika or cayenne adds warmth and color.
• Chopped fresh chives introduce a mild onion finish.

Serving Suggestions

Arby’s Horsey Sauce goes far beyond sandwiches:

• Roast beef: Classic combination, perfect for dipping or smearing inside a bun.
• Grilled meats: Complements steak, pork chops, and ribs.
• Burgers and sliders: Add a spoonful for a zesty burger sauce.
• Chicken tenders or nuggets: Use as an alternative to honey mustard or ranch.
• Vegetables: Try it with baked potatoes, grilled asparagus, or roasted carrots.
• Seafood: Works as a tangy dip for fried fish or crab cakes.

Need a dipping sauce for fries or onion rings? This creamy, peppery blend never disappoints.

Tips for the Best Results

• Use quality mayonnaise for a smooth base—the fresher, the better.
• Stir horseradish before measuring to ensure even consistency.
• Let the sauce rest so the flavors settle; fresh sauce will taste sharper, while chilled sauce is more balanced.
• Don’t freeze the sauce, as mayonnaise loses texture after thawing.
• Use clean utensils each time you dip into your jar to keep the sauce fresh longer.

Storage Instructions

Store your finished Horsey Sauce in a jar with a tight-fitting lid. It will keep in the fridge for up to two weeks. If you notice separation or a sour smell, it’s time to make a new batch.

The Story Behind Horseradish

The central flavor in Horsey Sauce comes from horseradish, a root vegetable prized for its spicy notes. Prepared horseradish, sold in jars, combines grated root, vinegar, and salt. The pungency comes from compounds released when the root is chopped or grated, which fade over time.

Did you know? In early Europe, horseradish was seen as both food and medicine. Today, it’s popular in sauces and condiments, from cocktail sauce to wasabi alternatives.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Horsey Sauce taste like?
It’s creamy with a sharp, nose-tingling zing from the horseradish, balanced by a mellow sweetness.

Can I make it ahead?
Absolutely. In fact, a night in the refrigerator helps the sauce develop even better flavor.

Is it dairy-free?
Yes, as long as you use standard mayonnaise.

Can I substitute the horseradish?
Horseradish’s unique punch is key, but wasabi paste or hot mustard offers a different, though not identical, bite.

Sample Variations Table

Replicating Arby’s Horsey Sauce at home is straightforward and rewarding. You gain freedom—adjusting spice, sweetness, and tang for your taste. With just a few ingredients and a couple of minutes, you’ll have a sauce that brings zest to roast beef, excitement to burgers, and a welcome spark to veggies. Mix up a batch for your next meal, and you may wonder how you ever got by without it.